July 19, 2007

"[A] Case About Nothing"

rare clarity from a dissenting appeals court opinion, written by judge who admittedly did not bother to read the majority's decision. From the fine folks at Opinion Journal.com. Read it.

Posted by LMC at July 19, 2007 08:13 AM | TrackBack

I would nominate said judge for the next SCOTUS opening...For his sense of humor alone.

Posted by: kmr at July 19, 2007 06:09 PM

Man, he just ROCKS . . .

" . . . Contrary to the impression created by the majority's lengthy formal opinion, this case is not a cause célèbre; it is a slow-motion tantrum by children spending their graduate years trying to humiliate the school that conferred on them a costly education from which they evidently derived small benefit. A selection from the illiterate piffle in the disputed issue of the College Voice is set out in the margin for the reader's fun."

I mean, this is the kind of stuff you'd get if you put Robbo on the bench. It's gold, Jerry. Pure gold.

Posted by: The Colossus at July 19, 2007 09:15 PM