April 18, 2007

Hear, Hear

Steyn on the culture of passivity:

We do our children a disservice to raise them to entrust all to officialdom’s security blanket. Geraldo-like “protection” is a delusion: when something goes awry — whether on a September morning flight out of Logan or on a peaceful college campus — the state won’t be there to protect you. You’ll be the fellow on the scene who has to make the decision.

'Zackly.

I don't say anything about this statement in relation to the Virginia Tech massacre per se (the nucleus of Steyn's column) because we really don't know what happened yet. But as a general proposition, as I raise up three girls who will one day have to make their own ways out into a world full of awfulness, I feel it's of fundamental importance that I teach them not to be sheep, but to recognize when they need to step up and take things into their own hands.

UPDATE: Ace has a different take, focusing on Steyn's remarks as they do pertain to the kids at Tech, and opining that they are unfair and overstated. However, as Ace himself admits and as I say above, we don't really know what happened.

Ace's point about what people can/might/will do in crisis situations is fair enough. But I continue to believe that Steyn has a valid larger argument about unrealistic reliance on the state security blanket to protect us all, particularly "the Children" at all times. "A pack, not a herd" was popular rhetoric after 9/11 but seems to have dropped off somewhat. Steyn's message about the dangers of passivity is, I believe, simply a variant on that same theme.

Posted by Robert at April 18, 2007 02:48 PM | TrackBack
Comments

A gun safety course when they are old enough might be a good idea, too. If I had daughters, I would teach them how to operate a handgun safely, and how to shoot. What's the old saying? "God made men, but Sam Colt made men equal?"

A 90lb. woman with a handgun, who knows how to shoot, is the equal or better of any man in a fight. Mrs. C. is not a particularly imposing or scary woman -- until you bring her targets in from down range.

Primitive, barbaric, and an unpleasant subject to contemplate, no doubt. But we live in an age less civilized than that of our parents and grandparents. Why take chances?

Posted by: The Colossus at April 18, 2007 03:30 PM