January 18, 2007
That's My Church!
Well that didn't take long:
Diocesan Leadership Declares Church Property ‘Abandoned’For release: Thursday, January 18, 2007
Contact: Patrick Getlein 1-800 346-2373 x 30
Today, January 18, 2007, the Executive Board of the Diocese of Virginia took a step forward in preserving the mission and ministry of the Diocese and the Episcopal Church for current and future generations of Episcopalians and adopted a resolution concerning the property of 11 Episcopal Churches where a majority of members – including the vestry and clergy – have left The Episcopal Church but have not relinquished Church property and have continued to occupy the churches and use the property owned by the Diocese.Specifically, the Executive Board declared the property of those churches – real and personal – to be abandoned in accordance with the Canons of the Diocese.
“All real and personal property held by or for the benefit of any Church or Mission within this Diocese is held in trust for The Episcopal Church and the Diocese of Virginia.” (Canon 15.1)
“No part of the real property of a Church, except abandoned property, shall be alienated, sold, exchanged, encumbered or otherwise transferred for any purpose without the consent of the congregation … [and] the Bishop, acting with the advice and consent of the Standing Committee of the Diocese.” (Canon 15.2)
Having declared the property abandoned for the purposes for which it is set aside, namely the mission of the Episcopal Church and the Diocese of Virginia, the Executive Board is required to protect the property, according to the Canons:“[W]henever any property, real or personal, formerly owned or used by any congregation of the Episcopal Church in the Diocese of Virginia for any purpose for which religious congregations are authorized to hold property under the provisions of the Code of Virginia or any amendment thereof, has ceased to be so occupied or used by such congregation, so that the same may be regarded as abandoned property by the Executive Board, which shall have the authority to declare such property abandoned and shall have the authority to take charge and custody thereof, the Executive Board shall take such steps as may be necessary to transfer the property to the Bishop…” (Canon 15.3)
The unanimous decision by the Executive Board also authorizes the Bishop to take such steps as may be necessary to recover or secure such real and personal property.
In addition, the Standing Committee met today for its regular monthly meeting and took up the issue of the status of the clergy attached to these congregations. Following today’s meeting the Standing Committee will communicate its determination to the Bishop according to the Canons.
The 11 churches where property has been declared abandoned are:
Church of the Redeemer, Chantilly
Church of the Apostles, Fairfax
Church of the Epiphany, Herndon
Church of Our Saviour, Oatlands
Church of the Word, Gainesville
Potomac Falls Church, Sterling
St. Margaret’s, Woodbridge
St. Paul’s, Haymarket
St. Stephen’s, Heathsville
Truro, Fairfax
The Falls Church, Falls Church
In effect, Ft. Sumter has fired on Charleston Harbor.
There's also an accompanying letter from the Rt. Rev. Peter Lee, Bishop of Virginny that even mentions your humble correspondent! It's too long to post in its entirety and the link isn't up at the Diocesan homepage yet, but here's a sample:
In the coming days and months there will be many opinions aired in the media, in letters and in countless blogs, opinions disguised as facts. I urge you to turn away from those as the distracting noise of the world intended to take your mind and your heart off the mission of the Church. Instead, I urge you to pray for our brothers and sisters who have moved to separate themselves from us. I urge us to remember that in their call away from the Episcopal Church, they may be responding to a genuine call to new ministry in a different place and in a different way. The Episcopal Church and the Diocese of Virginia will mourn their loss. We will suffer from their absence in ways we cannot know at this time in our life. I believe that they, too, will know times when our absence from their life will be a source of great sorrow for them.
Emphasis added. It's a weird letter, a combination of soothing happy-speak to the Faithful and ranting diatribe against the secessionists (and anybody else hesitating about holding the party line) that reminds me somewhat of Saruman trying to deal piece-meal with Gandalf, Theoden & Co. from his balcony at Orthanc.
And Bishop Lee? As a "distracting noise of the world" I humbly thank you for your support.
I'll post the links when they come up.
UPDATE: I hear ya, Coloss. Well, they don't call us Whiskeypalians for nothing. (NQSFW):
Double-Secret Probation, indeed.
UPDATE DEUX: Here's the news release. And here's Saruman's Bishop Lee's letter. "Dotard! What is the house of Eorl but a thatched barn where the brigands drink in the reek and their brats roll on the floor among the dogs!"
Maybe this will cheer you up.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-uU_1GQlaDY
Robbo, I feel for you. I hope that whether you stay or go, you find a place where God speaks to you, where your faith is rewarded, and where your talents are appreciated.
Well, Robbo, the powers that be in the Episcopal Church has taken its toll on our local parish as well. So much so that we're moving on. We weren't nearly as deeply involved in ours as you are in yours, though, so it hasn't caused nearly as much anguish. I may even drag my better half down to the Methodist gutter where I cut my teeth. We'll see - thanks for the continued EC coverage.
Posted by: Preston Taylor Holmes at January 18, 2007 09:27 PMDon't worry, Robbo--I'll bake a file in a cake so you can break out of the Tower when you are locked up.
Posted by: Steve the LLamabutcher at January 19, 2007 09:31 AMRobbo, how does the diocese lay claim to parishes which predate the existance of ECUSA? With the creation of ECUSA did the parishes sign over all property?
Posted by: Mike at January 19, 2007 10:37 AMNo one expects the Episcopalian Inquisition.
Posted by: rbj at January 19, 2007 10:40 AMMike - I understand that this is the million dollar question at stake. From what I gather, neither the deed of Truro or of the Falls Church contains any language referencing the Diocese. But the Diocese will argue there's an implied trust, created when these churches became part of the ECUSA.
Now, I'm no expert but I'm told that Virginia courts do not look kindly on implied trusts. On the other hand, they don't like to muck about with the internal workings of the Church when they don't have to. I would say that whatever legal battles develop will pit these considerations against each other.
What will be the result? Beats me.
Posted by: Robbo the LB at January 19, 2007 11:30 AMRobbo --- similar situation in Colorado, where a leading conservative rector in Colorado Springs (co-founder of the Anglican Institute Rev. Don Armstrong) has been summarily removed from his position by the bishop while "financial improprieties" have been alleged --- there has been no evidence brought forth and no charges, so he cannot even privately or publicly defend himself. In the meantime, the congregation has stopped writing checks so the church is perilously close to bankruptcy....just what the bishop wants to allow him to take it over. Despicable.
Posted by: Aggravated DocSurg at January 19, 2007 11:44 AMNow would be a good time for Benedict to roll out an Anglican rite for the RCC.
Posted by: LMC at January 19, 2007 12:35 PMI soured on Peter Lee years ago when he forced my alma mater, St. Stephen's School in Alexandria, to merge with the smaller St. Agnes (girls school), and put St. Agnes' head as headmistress of the combined schools. He was high-handed, hurt many feelings, and Til Hazel asked for and received back his >$1 million recent donation. My dad and I haven't sent them more than $50 since, but it doesn't stop them from asking.
I think the ECUSA will bite off its own nose to spite the "dissenters", as they did with Robinson (I won't call him bishop, and I'm a fruit myself).
Not surprisingly, the school has gone much more PC than it was in the 70's. We used the 1928 prayer book, and I heard they continued until certain older faculty retired or died.
People I knew in Chapel Hill, NC, thought Lee was great when he was there, but then, they were in Chapel Hill, the bluest and snootiest part of the Blue Research Triangle.
Posted by: Ralph L. at January 20, 2007 03:12 PM